I came to Rhode Island, not in search of fame,
But the last man executed there, is how they know my name.
My brother called me over, on a dreary Irish day,
So I could know the pleasure, of honest work and pay.
But there were other plans for me, things that I just couldn't see.
The power and the bigotry as at large.
I soon found out that I was framed,
They said I killed a man they named...Amasa,
And his brother let the charge.

Still it's so unclear to me. I know he had some words to speak,
about my brother's store where his workers went, to take the edge off with a drink.
Amasa didn't like to think of working men with power in their minds,
and on a broken New Year's Eve, Amasa met his destiny
Fingers pointed right at me and sent me to my grave.
And so it was they did decide to march me out and hang me high,
"Someone has to pay," they cried, "John Gordon you must die."

It would take more than a century for righteous men to pardon me,
But no one saw my innocence in time.
In the court room where I met my fate, they cleared my name though far too late,
I'll thank you all on the other side.
I just hope that you will learn from me and use the law with dignity
And never let emotions run the way, for when dealing with the lives of men
The facts must speak and only then will we escape the tragedies we make.
Can we escape the tragedies we make?
We must escape the tragedies we make.